174 replies to this topic

[Witas]

Jak na razie tylko Pride i Running To Stand Still trzymają średnią 10,0

[pablo]

BOY 7

01. I Will Follow 8
02. Twilight 6
03. An Cat Dubh 5
04. Into The Heart 7
05. Out Of Control 5
06. Stories For Boys 9
07. The Ocean 6
08. A Day Without Me 6
09. Another Time, Another Place 5
10. The Electric Co. 5
11. Shadows And Tall Trees 10


OCTOBER 6

01. Gloria 6
02. I Fall Down 5
03. I Threw A Brick Through A Window 6
04. Rejoice 8
05. Fire 3
06. Tomorrow 9
07. October 8
08. With A Shout (Jerusalem) 8
09. Stranger In A Strange Land 5
10. Scarlet 5
11. Is That All? 7

WAR 7

01. Sunday Bloody Sunday 8
02. Seconds 5
03. New Year's Day 8
04. Like A Song 9
05. Drowning Man 6
06. The Refugee 5
07. Two Hearts Beat As One 7
08. Red Light 4
09. Surrender 5
10. '40' 7


THE UNFORGETTABLE FIRE 8

01. A Sort Of Homecoming 7
02. Pride (In The Name Of Love) 7
03. Wire 8
04. The Unforgettable Fire 10
05. Promenade 7
06. 4th Of July 1
07. Bad 6
08. Indian Summer Sky 8
09. Elvis Presley And America 7
10. MLK 8


THE JOSHUA TREE 9

01. Where The Streets Have No Name 9
02. I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For 7
03. With Or Without You 9
04. Bullet The Blue Sky 6
05. Running To Stand Still 5
06. Red Hill Mining Town 8
07. In God's Country 9
08. Trip Through Your Wires 9
09. One Tree Hill 8
10. Exit 10
11. Mothers Of The Disappeared 9


RATTLE AND HUM 6

02. Van Diemen's Land 7
03. Desire 7
04. Hawkmoon 269 7
10. Angel Of Harlem 7
11. Love Rescue Me 8
12. When Love Comes To Town 3
13. Heartland 9
14. God Part II 7
17. All I Want Is You 10


ACHTUNG BABY 9

01. Zoo Station 9
02. Even Better Than The Real Thing 8
03. One 8
04. Until The End Of The World 7
05. Who's Gonna Ride Your Wild Horses 9
06. So Cruel 8
07. The Fly 8
08. Mysterious Ways 5
09. Tryin' To Throw Your Arms Around The World 6
10. Ultraviolet (Light My Way) 10
11. Acrobat 10
12. Love Is Blindness 9


ZOOROPA 7

01. Zooropa 8
02. Babyface 8
03. Numb 3
04. Lemon 7
05. Stay (Faraway, So Close!) 7
06. Daddy's Gonna Pay For Your Crashed Car 7
07. Some Days Are Better Than Others 8
08. The First Time 7
09. Dirty Day 9
10. The Wanderer 6


POP 8

01. Discotheque 8
02. Do You Feel Loved? 9
03. Mofo 8
04. If God Will Send His Angels 4
05. Staring At The Sun 4
06. Last Night On Earth 9
07. Gone 9
08. Miami 2
09. The Playboy Mansion 6
10. If You Wear That Velvet Dress 7
11. Please 6 (wersja singlowa dostała by 8)
12. Wake Up Dead Man 6


ALL THAT YOU CAN'T LEAVE BEHIND 8

01. Beautiful Day 7
02. Stuck In A Moment (You Can't Get Out Of) 7
03. Elevation 7 (wersja teledyskowa z czadem na końcu dostałaby 8)
04. Walk On 7 (wersja singlowa dostałaby 9)
05. Kite 9
06. In A Little While 4
07. Wild Honey 5
08. Peace On Earth 8
09. When I Look At The World 9
10. New York 9
11. Grace 4


HOW TO DISMANTLE AN ATOMIC BOMB 8

01. Vertigo 8
02. Miracle Drug 7
03. Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own 10
04. Love And Peace Or Else 8
05. City Of Blinding Lights 8
06. All Because Of You 6
07. A Man And A Woman 5
08. Crumbs From Your Table 7
09. One Step Closer 7
10. Original Of The Species 9
11. Yahweh 8
12. Fast Cars 7

[acr]

01. Gloria 6
05. Running To Stand Still 5

vs.

02. Even Better Than The Real Thing 8
06. So Cruel 8
01. Vertigo 8

I właśnie m.in. dlatego nigdy się nie zrozumiemy.
Aha, nie wierzę ludziom, którzy nie dali ani jednej jedynki.

Edited by acr, 12 lutego 2009 - 13:47 .

[pablo]

I właśnie m.in. dlatego nigdy się nie zrozumiemy.
Aha, nie wierzę ludziom, którzy nie dali ani jednej jedynki.

Czemu? W końcu wspólnym mianownikiem i tak pozostanie uwielbienie dla U2.
A jedną jedynkę też dałem (4th Of July)




.

[Witas]

Pablo:
October - 6
HTDAAB - 8

??








Powiedzieć należy, że typy można edytować w dowolnym momencie. To nie survivor.

[Fledge]

Powiem szczerze, że sam chciałem założyć taki temat. Dobry pomysł. Jak zdam jutro egzamin to wrzuce własną listę. A jak nie zdam to wrzuce w sobote.

[acr]

Czemu? W końcu wspólnym mianownikiem i tak pozostanie uwielbienie dla U2.

Trochę "innego" U2 jednak, co głębiej się przekłada chyba na inną wrażliwość odbioru muzyki w ogóle, trochę inne oczekiwania względem niej

A jedną jedynkę też dałem (4th Of July)

Świetny ambient to jest. Przede wszystkim atmosfera.
Ja ten kawałek czuję i on się materializuje w przestrzeni podczas słuchania. U mnie chyba ma 5, właśnie za to

[Witas]

6*

[rupak9]

Boy 7

01. I Will Follow 9
02. Twilight 7
03. An Cat Dubh 7
04. Into The Heart 7
05. Out Of Control 8
06. Stories For Boys 6
07. The Ocean 4
08. A Day Without Me 6
09. Another Time, Another Place 6
10. The Electric Co. 8
11. Shadows And Tall Trees 7


October 6

01. Gloria 8
02. I Fall Down 5
03. I Threw A Brick Through A Window 6
04. Rejoice 5
05. Fire 7
06. Tomorrow 8
07. October 8
08. With A Shout (Jerusalem) 6
09. Stranger In A Strange Land 7
10. Scarlet 5
11. Is That All? 5


War 7

01. Sunday Bloody Sunday 8
02. Seconds 6
03. New Year's Day 10
04. Like A Song 9
05. Drowning Man 7
06. The Refugee 6
07. Two Hearts Beat As One 7
08. Red Light 6
09. Surrender 7
10. '40' 8


The Unforgettable Fire 7[b/]

01. A Sort Of Homecoming 7
02. Pride (In The Name Of Love) 10
03. Wire 8
04. The Unforgettable Fire 10
05. Promenade 7
06. 4th Of July 6
07. Bad 10
08. Indian Summer Sky 7
09. Elvis Presley And America 8
10. MLK 8


The Joshua Tree (10)

01. Where The Streets Have No Name 10
02. I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For 10
03. With Or Without You 10
04. Bullet The Blue Sky 9
05. Running To Stand Still 8
06. Red Hill Mining Town 9
07. In God's Country 8
08. Trip Through Your Wires 8
09. One Tree Hill 9
10. Exit 9
11. Mothers Of The Disappeared 9


Rattle And Hum 7

02. Van Diemen's Land 7
03. Desire 8
04. Hawkmoon 269 6
10. Angel Of Harlem 5
11. Love Rescue Me 6
12. When Love Comes To Town 7
13. Heartland 8
14. God Part II 7
17. All I Want Is You 10


Achtung Baby 10

01. Zoo Station 9
02. Even Better Than The Real Thing 8
03. One 10
04. Until The End Of The World 8
05. Who's Gonna Ride Your Wild Horses 10
06. So Cruel 9
07. The Fly 9
08. Mysterious Ways 8
09. Tryin' To Throw Your Arms Around The World 7
10. Ultraviolet (Light My Way) 10
11. Acrobat 10
12. Love Is Blindness 8


ZOOROPA 9

01. Zooropa 10
02. Babyface 8
03. Numb 9
04. Lemon 7
05. Stay (Faraway, So Close!) 8
06. Daddy's Gonna Pay For Your Crashed Car 8
07. Some Days Are Better Than Others 7
08. The First Time 7
09. Dirty Day 7
10. The Wanderer 7


POP 4

01. Discotheque 6
02. Do You Feel Loved? 8
03. Mofo 8
04. If God Will Send His Angels 7
05. Staring At The Sun 6
06. Last Night On Earth 4
07. Gone 4
08. Miami 5
09. The Playboy Mansion 2
10. If You Wear That Velvet Dress 7
11. Please (7)
12. Wake Up Dead Man (9)


All That You Can't Leave Behind 9

01. Beautiful Day 10
02. Stuck In A Moment (You Can't Get Out Of) 8
03. Elevation 9
04. Walk On 8
05. Kite 6
06. In A Little While 7
07. Wild Honey 6
08. Peace On Earth 8
09. When I Look At The World 8
10. New York 7
11. Grace 8


How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb 7

01. Vertigo 8
02. Miracle Drug 8
03. Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own 7
04. Love And Peace Or Else 10
05. City Of Blinding Lights 10
06. All Because Of You 7
07. A Man And A Woman 4
08. Crumbs From Your Table 7
09. One Step Closer 8
10. Original Of The Species 8
11. Yahweh 8
12. Fast Cars [b]7

[Weronika]

jo, a zrobię se swój jakoś jutro, mimo ze mi głośniki padły

ale jedno powiem: za wysokie oceny dla 'So Cruel' :|

[Jacek]

A proszę was bardzo:


BOY (8)

01. I Will Follow (8)
02. Twilight (6)
03. An Cat Dubh (6)
04. Into The Heart (6)
05. Out Of Control (9)
06. Stories For Boys (8)
07. The Ocean (5)
08. A Day Without Me (7)
09. Another Time, Another Place (7)
10. The Electric Co. (7)
11. Shadows And Tall Trees (8)


OCTOBER (7)

01. Gloria (9)
02. I Fall Down (5)
03. I Threw A Brick Through A Window (5)
04. Rejoice (6)
05. Fire (6)
06. Tomorrow (6)
07. October (8)
08. With A Shout (Jerusalem) (8)
09. Stranger In A Strange Land (6)
10. Scarlet (4)
11. Is That All? (6)


WAR (8)

01. Sunday Bloody Sunday (8)
02. Seconds (7)
03. New Year's Day (7)
04. Like A Song (9)
05. Drowning Man (6)
06. The Refugee (6)
07. Two Hearts Beat As One (9)
08. Red Light (7)
09. Surrender (7)
10. '40' (7)


THE UNFORGETTABLE FIRE (9)

01. A Sort Of Homecoming (8)
02. Pride (In The Name Of Love) (10)
03. Wire (7)
04. The Unforgettable Fire (9)
05. Promenade (7)
06. 4th Of July (6)
07. Bad (9)
08. Indian Summer Sky (8)
09. Elvis Presley And America (6)
10. MLK (6)


THE JOSHUA TREE (10)

01. Where The Streets Have No Name (10)
02. I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For (10)
03. With Or Without You (10)
04. Bullet The Blue Sky (7)
05. Running To Stand Still (10)
06. Red Hill Mining Town (10)
07. In God's Country (10)
08. Trip Through Your Wires (8)
09. One Tree Hill (10)
10. Exit (10)
11. Mothers Of The Disappeared (10)


RATTLE AND HUM (5)

02. Van Diemen's Land (5)
03. Desire (5)
04. Hawkmoon 269 (4)
10. Angel Of Harlem (7)
11. Love Rescue Me (7)
12. When Love Comes To Town (7)
13. Heartland (5)
14. God Part II (5)
17. All I Want Is You (7)


ACHTUNG BABY (8)

01. Zoo Station (7)
02. Even Better Than The Real Thing (6)
03. One (8)
04. Until The End Of The World (7)
05. Who's Gonna Ride Your Wild Horses (10)
06. So Cruel (6)
07. The Fly (8)
08. Mysterious Ways (8)
09. Tryin' To Throw Your Arms Around The World (6)
10. Ultraviolet (Light My Way) (8)
11. Acrobat (8)
12. Love Is Blindness (9)


ZOOROPA (6)

01. Zooropa (7)
02. Babyface (5)
03. Numb (5)
04. Lemon (5)
05. Stay (Faraway, So Close!) (8)
06. Daddy's Gonna Pay For Your Crashed Car (7)
07. Some Days Are Better Than Others (5)
08. The First Time (7)
09. Dirty Day (5)
10. The Wanderer (7)


POP (8)

01. Discotheque (7)
02. Do You Feel Loved? (6)
03. Mofo (7)
04. If God Will Send His Angels (9)
05. Staring At The Sun (7)
06. Last Night On Earth (5)
07. Gone (8)
08. Miami (7) (za papa - pa - pa - pa - pa)
09. The Playboy Mansion (6)
10. If You Wear That Velvet Dress (8)
11. Please (8)
12. Wake Up Dead Man (10)


ALL THAT YOU CAN'T LEAVE BEHIND (8)

01. Beautiful Day (5)
02. Stuck In A Moment (You Can't Get Out Of) (6)
03. Elevation (6)
04. Walk On (8)
05. Kite (8)
06. In A Little While (10)
07. Wild Honey (9)
08. Peace On Earth (7)
09. When I Look At The World (9)
10. New York (9)
11. Grace (7)


HOW TO DISMANTLE AN ATOMIC BOMB - SSIE PAŁKĘ DO POTĘGI ENTEJ

01. Vertigo (1)
02. Miracle Drug (5)
03. Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own (5)
04. Love And Peace Or Else (5)
05. City Of Blinding Lights (1)
06. All Because Of You (0)
07. A Man And A Woman (1)
08. Crumbs From Your Table (5)
09. One Step Closer (1)
10. Original Of The Species (5)
11. Yahweh (5)
12. Fast Cars (2)


PS. Poprawcie mnie jeżeli nie mam racji

[Johnny99]

Moje oceny na dziś.

Boy 7

01. I Will Follow 10
02. Twilight 9
03. An Cat Dubh 9
04. Into The Heart 9
05. Out Of Control 6
06. Stories For Boys 5
07. The Ocean 8
08. A Day Without Me 5
09. Another Time, Another Place 10
10. The Electric Co. 8
11. Shadows And Tall Trees 10


October 8

01. Gloria 10
02. I Fall Down 4
03. I Threw A Brick Through A Window 4
04. Rejoice 6
05. Fire 9
06. Tomorrow 10
07. October 10
08. With A Shout (Jerusalem) 8
09. Stranger In A Strange Land 8
10. Scarlet 10
11. Is That All? 7


War 10

01. Sunday Bloody Sunday 10
02. Seconds 10
03. New Year's Day 10
04. Like A Song 10
05. Drowning Man 10
06. The Refugee 7
07. Two Hearts Beat As One 9
08. Red Light 8
09. Surrender 10
10. '40' 10


The Unforgettable Fire 10

01. A Sort Of Homecoming 10
02. Pride (In The Name Of Love) 10
03. Wire 10
04. The Unforgettable Fire 10
05. Promenade 8
06. 4th Of July 8
07. Bad 10
08. Indian Summer Sky 9
09. Elvis Presley And America 9
10. MLK 9


The Joshua Tree 10

01. Where The Streets Have No Name 10
02. I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For 10
03. With Or Without You 10
04. Bullet The Blue Sky 10
05. Running To Stand Still 10
06. Red Hill Mining Town 10
07. In God's Country 10
08. Trip Through Your Wires 8
09. One Tree Hill 10
10. Exit 10
11. Mothers Of The Disappeared 10


Rattle And Hum 9

02. Van Diemen's Land 6
03. Desire 7
04. Hawkmoon 269 8
10. Angel Of Harlem 8
11. Love Rescue Me 7
12. When Love Comes To Town 9
13. Heartland 10
14. God Part II 5
17. All I Want Is You 8


Achtung Baby 2

01. Zoo Station 7
02. Even Better Than The Real Thing 1
03. One 10
04. Until The End Of The World 7
05. Who's Gonna Ride Your Wild Horses 1
06. So Cruel 1
07. The Fly 3
08. Mysterious Ways 1
09. Tryin' To Throw Your Arms Around The World 9
10. Ultraviolet (Light My Way) 2
11. Acrobat 9
12. Love Is Blindness 9


ZOOROPA 7

01. Zooropa 8
02. Babyface 5
03. Numb 6
04. Lemon 9
05. Stay (Faraway, So Close!) 7
06. Daddy's Gonna Pay For Your Crashed Car 8
07. Some Days Are Better Than Others 5
08. The First Time 7
09. Dirty Day 6
10. The Wanderer 10


POP 9

01. Discotheque 7
02. Do You Feel Loved? 9
03. Mofo 9
04. If God Will Send His Angels 5
05. Staring At The Sun 6
06. Last Night On Earth 8
07. Gone 7
08. Miami 10
09. The Playboy Mansion 4
10. If You Wear That Velvet Dress 10
11. Please 10
12. Wake Up Dead Man 5


All That You Can't Leave Behind 9

01. Beautiful Day 7
02. Stuck In A Moment (You Can't Get Out Of) 10
03. Elevation 6
04. Walk On 9
05. Kite 10
06. In A Little While 8
07. Wild Honey 8
08. Peace On Earth 10
09. When I Look At The World 10
10. New York 7
11. Grace 8


How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb 3

01. Vertigo 7
02. Miracle Drug 2
03. Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own 10
04. Love And Peace Or Else 5
05. City Of Blinding Lights 5
06. All Because Of You 6
07. A Man And A Woman 6
08. Crumbs From Your Table 7
09. One Step Closer 10
10. Original Of The Species 2
11. Yahweh 7
12. Fast Cars 7

[acr]

Achtung Baby 2
How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb 3

Przeginasz zią.. ech.. no już bez przesady.. żeby to odwrotnie było, to bym tego AB zrozumiał jeszcze jakoś, no ale.. że Bomba niby lepsza.. naprawdę, nawet ja nie rozumiem, a mój stosunek do tych płyt jest dość powszechnie raczej znany

[marcin93]

Ale Dżony doznaje 'Into the heart' i 'One step closer' i dlatego jest fajny

[Johnny99]

Już to chyba kiedyś wyjaśniałem - jeśli chodzi o jakości " górne " to Achtung stoi nieco wyżej, natomiast niestety decydują przegięcia w dół, których HTDAAB ma zdecydowanie mniej.

[Jacek]

Już to chyba kiedyś wyjaśniałem - jeśli chodzi o jakości " górne " to Achtung stoi nieco wyżej, natomiast niestety decydują przegięcia w dół, których HTDAAB ma zdecydowanie mniej.

Eyyyeee, że jak?? Proszę o rozwinięcie.

[acr]

Eyyyeee, że jak?? Proszę o rozwinięcie.

Nie no, to ja się zgadzam. Sinusoidalna ta płyta jest jak cholera, od dziesiątek po ledwo dwójki. Ale żeby od razu całościowo tak polecieć.. nie.. nadal nie rozumiem..

[Johnny99]

@Johnny średnia twoich głosów na AB to 5, tak z ciekawości sprawdziłem ; )

A inne średnie ?

Eyyyeee, że jak?? Proszę o rozwinięcie.

No zobacz na moje zestawienie. Na HTDAAB mamy dwie dwójki, i żadnej jedynki. Na Achtungu zaczynamy skalę od czterech jedynek.. sprawa jest jasna. Ja NAPRAWDĘ uważam, że jak na możliwości U2 takie Wild Horses czy So Cruel to są olbrzymie cienizny, godne co najwyżej b-sidu, a i to nie do końca, bo U2 mają mnóstwo odrzutów lepszych o kilka skal ( Endless Deep, Spanish Eyes, Mercy, Deep In The Heart, Be There.. ).

[Chico la verdad]

BOY (9)

01. I Will Follow (9)
02. Twilight (7)
03. An Cat Dubh (9)
04. Into The Heart (9)
05. Out Of Control (9)
06. Stories For Boys (8)
07. The Ocean (8)
08. A Day Without Me (9)
09. Another Time, Another Place (8)
10. The Electric Co. (9)
11. Shadows And Tall Trees (7)


OCTOBER (6)

01. Gloria (9)
02. I Fall Down (6)
03. I Threw A Brick Through A Window (6)
04. Rejoice (5)
05. Fire (5)
06. Tomorrow (4)
07. October (9)
08. With A Shout (Jerusalem) (6)
09. Stranger In A Strange Land (6)
10. Scarlet (3)
11. Is That All? (7)


WAR (8)

01. Sunday Bloody Sunday (7)
02. Seconds (7)
03. New Year's Day (9)
04. Like A Song (8)
05. Drowning Man (6)
06. The Refugee (5)
07. Two Hearts Beat As One (9)
08. Red Light (6)
09. Surrender (8)
10. '40' (8)


THE UNFORGETTABLE FIRE (9)

01. A Sort Of Homecoming (8)
02. Pride (In The Name Of Love) (10)
03. Wire (8)
04. The Unforgettable Fire (9)
05. Promenade (8)
06. 4th Of July (7)
07. Bad (10)
08. Indian Summer Sky (8)
09. Elvis Presley And America (5)
10. MLK (7)


THE JOSHUA TREE (10)

01. Where The Streets Have No Name (10)
02. I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For (10)
03. With Or Without You (10)
04. Bullet The Blue Sky (9)
05. Running To Stand Still (9)
06. Red Hill Mining Town (10)
07. In God's Country (10)
08. Trip Through Your Wires (7)
09. One Tree Hill (10)
10. Exit (10)
11. Mothers Of The Disappeared (9)


RATTLE AND HUM (8)

02. Van Diemen's Land (6)
03. Desire (8)
04. Hawkmoon 269 (7)
10. Angel Of Harlem (9)
11. Love Rescue Me (7)
12. When Love Comes To Town (8)
13. Heartland (7)
14. God Part II (6)
17. All I Want Is You (9)


ACHTUNG BABY (7)

01. Zoo Station (8)
02. Even Better Than The Real Thing (5)
03. One (8)
04. Until The End Of The World (7)
05. Who's Gonna Ride Your Wild Horses (7)
06. So Cruel (6)
07. The Fly (8)
08. Mysterious Ways (7)
09. Tryin' To Throw Your Arms Around The World (7)
10. Ultraviolet (Light My Way) (7)
11. Acrobat (7)
12. Love Is Blindness (9)


ZOOROPA (5)

01. Zooropa (7)
02. Babyface (4)
03. Numb (6)
04. Lemon (6)
05. Stay (Faraway, So Close!) (8)
06. Daddy's Gonna Pay For Your Crashed Car (5)
07. Some Days Are Better Than Others (5)
08. The First Time (4)
09. Dirty Day (6)
10. The Wanderer (7)


POP (8)

01. Discotheque (8)
02. Do You Feel Loved? (6)
03. Mofo (9)
04. If God Will Send His Angels (9)
05. Staring At The Sun (7)
06. Last Night On Earth (8)
07. Gone (8)
08. Miami (8)
09. The Playboy Mansion (7)
10. If You Wear That Velvet Dress (8)
11. Please (8)
12. Wake Up Dead Man (8)


ALL THAT YOU CAN'T LEAVE BEHIND (7)

01. Beautiful Day (7)
02. Stuck In A Moment (You Can't Get Out Of) (8)
03. Elevation (6)
04. Walk On (8)
05. Kite (8)
06. In A Little While (7)
07. Wild Honey (7)
08. Peace On Earth (6)
09. When I Look At The World (9)
10. New York (7)
11. Grace (6)


HOW TO DISMANTLE AN ATOMIC BOMB (7)

01. Vertigo (7)
02. Miracle Drug (8)
03. Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own (9)
04. Love And Peace Or Else (8)
05. City Of Blinding Lights (9)
06. All Because Of You (7)
07. A Man And A Woman (5)
08. Crumbs From Your Table (5)
09. One Step Closer (7)
10. Original Of The Species (7)
11. Yahweh (4)
12. Fast Cars (4)